16 Inspiring Amish Christmas Books for Your TBR List
Amish Christmas fiction
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from purchases made through the affiliate links included in this post. This means if you click on the link and make a purchase, I will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. See the Privacy Policy for more information.
For bookish women who love a good story, Amish Christmas books are the perfect way to get into the holiday spirit. These stories offer an inspiring look at how faith and family can bring people together during the festive season.
Filled with heartwarming moments of joy and redemption, these novels take readers on a journey through the traditional values that make this time of year so special for those living in close-knit Amish communities.
With themes of forgiveness, hope, and humility explored throughout each narrative, these novels are sure to be cherished by readers long after they have finished reading them! From captivating romance to cozy mysteries set against a backdrop of the snowy countryside, Amish Christmas fiction offers something for every reader looking for a magical escape this winter season.
What is Amish second Christmas?
Celebrated by the Amish, Second Christmas is the day after Christmas, and is a time for families to come together and enjoy fellowship – from exchanging gifts and savoring delicious meals. Some communities will celebrate Old Christmas on January 6th as well. It’s an opportunity for communities to reconnect in meaningful ways while upholding their traditional holiday customs.
Who writes books about the Amish?
- Beverly Lewis
- Cindy Woodsmall
- Wanda Brunstetter
- Beth Wiseman
- Barbara Cameron
- Linda Castillo
- Vannetta Chapman
- Tricia Goyer
- Cynthia Keller
- Mindy Starns Clark
- Amy Clipston
- Patricia Davids
- Mary Ellis
- Jerry S Eicher
- Anna Schmidt
- Suzanne Woods Fisher
- Emma Miller
- Rosalind Lauer
- Kathleen Fuller
- Shelley Shepard Gray
- Charlotte Hubbard
- Paul L Gaus
- Laura V Hilton
- Karen Harper
- Marta Perry
- Beverly Lewis
- Kelly Long
Best Amish Christmas books
An Amish Wife for Christmas and Amish Christmas Memories by Patricia David
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.20 out of 5 stars
This Christmas, Bethany Martin, and Caleb Wittmer are each presented with a unique challenge: for Bethany to prove her worthiness in raising her siblings without the help of a husband; while for Caleb, it is taking in an amnesiac stranger named Rachel who disrupts his orderly life.
Both stories center around how they deal with their respective obstacles – will Michael’s secrets keep them apart? Will Rachel be able to find out where she belongs before leaving forever? Join these two characters on this journey as they strive towards finding love amidst the chaos!
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? I am so excited to have found this book! The two authors have managed to create an amazing story with interesting characters and a fun christmas setting.
Not only is it a great read, but I can also appreciate the contrasting writing styles of the two authors. Each one brings something unique and special to the overall tale, making it even more magical.
An Amish Christmas Caper by Samantha Price
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.56 out of 5 stars
When Mary’s widowed mom relies solely on her wages to make ends meet, she takes up an unexpected job as Mrs. Claus at the local department store – something that would not be approved by the Amish bishop or Nathan Miller who has caught her eye.
Meanwhile, unbeknownst to Mary is that while attempting to dodge potential suitors for herself, Mom also embarks upon a pretend relationship with someone special which leads them both into uncharted waters when it comes time for matters of the heart! Can these two find true joy amidst all their festive obligations?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This book is a great read for its engaging plotline and well-developed characters. The dialogue between the characters is really witty and funny, providing plenty of laugh-out-loud moments. The characters feel real and have a surprising depth to them, making them easy to root for.
White Christmas Pie by Wanda E. Brunstetter
Amish Christmas Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.12 out of 5 stars
Step into Amish country to explore the bittersweet love story between Will Henderson and Karen Yoder. With a desperate father searching for his son, this captivating romance will pull at your heartstrings as it follows Will’s emotional journey of uncovering answers from his past that have been haunting him since childhood.
As he strives towards finding those answers, can he overcome the obstacles in order to reunite with Karen and embrace their future together?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? The characters experience amazing emotional depth and growth throughout the story. Not only do they develop, but the central themes of faith and forgiveness are prominent, making it easy to draw parallels to real life. Plus, the writing style of the book is unique, which captivated me with its interesting plot lines and dialogue.
An Amish Christmas Bakery by Amy Clipston, Beth Wiseman, Kathleen Fuller, Kelly Irvin
Amish Romance Novella
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.21 out of 5 stars
In ‘Cookies and Cheer’ by Amy Clipston, Alyssa Byler, a baker looking to make her window display extra special for Christmas, finds an unexpected source of help – Kyle Smoker and his handmade cookie cutters. As the festive nativity scene she created with these tools brings success to her bakery business while also teaching her about the true meaning of this holiday season, love begins blossoming between two unlikely partners.
In Beth Wiseman’s ‘Loaves of Love’, Katie is struggling to keep her family bakery afloat during the holiday season, while also trying not to let go of their traditional values. Meanwhile, Henry is desperately waiting for courage and the opportunity to tell Katie his deep secret crush on her.
In Kathleen Fuller’s ‘Melting Hearts’ Mattie must reunite with Peter in order to take care of Carolyn’s wishes before Christmas arrives but soon discovers that there might be more than what meets the eye between them both.
Finally, Kelly Irvin’s ‘Cakes & Kisses’ follows Martha who works hard at her family bakery making cakes and pies until Ambrose enters as a delivery boy from school days which sparks an unexpected chemistry among them two only if they can find enough courage within themselves would love blossom this holiday season?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? These four Amish Christmas novellas are the ideal holiday read, providing a combination of heartwarming romance and tantalizing baking recipes. Each story features engaging characters that bring these tales to life!
Christmas Comes to Morning Star by Charlotte Hubbard
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.53 out of 5 stars
Twin sisters Molly and Marietta Helfing are looking forward to a joyous Christmas, with Marietta having overcome cancer and their noodle making business thriving. Despite the happy atmosphere, Molly is still pining for former tenant Pete Shetler and his dog Riley’s absence.
When Amish neighbors suffer from fire damage in their home, both twins extend an invitation of refuge – this brings back Pete as he returns to help rebuild the family house. As everybody wonders if these holidays will be blessed by two weddings occurring simultaneously at Morning Star; emotions run high between all characters involved!
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? Charlotte’s captivating writing style enthralled readers with her intricate characters and unique personalities. The sweet romance that was interwoven throughout the story added an extra layer of emotion, which made it a truly enjoyable read!
A Haven for Christmas by Patricia Davids
Amish Christmas Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.50 out of 5 stars
Becca Beachy, an Amish widow in need of help after an emergency, and Tully Lange, the English cowboy who lands on her farm by accident come together during Christmas to discover a forbidden yet beautiful love.
With his assistance, she sets out to give him a true Amish celebration filled with joyous moments that will stay forever in their hearts as they learn if this is just for now or meant to last.
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This heartwarming Amish Christmas book had an incredibly sweet romance, complex and well-developed characters, and a riveting plot! The story melted my heart as it showed how even during difficult times people can come together in the spirit of love and giving.
An Amish Christmas Wedding: Four Stories by Amy Clipston, Kathleen Fuller, Kelly Irvin, Vannetta Chapman
Amish Romance Novella’s
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.31 out of 5 stars
Celebrate the Christmas season with four heartwarming Amish novellas! In Evergreen Love, Amy Clipston tells a story of unexpected sparks between Leesa and Henry. Kelly Irvin’s Holiday of Hope brings two former friends together as they each contemplate their future.
Kathleen Fuller’s Wreathed in Joy narrates Mary Wengerd’s journey from friendship to love while caring for an injured dog leads Rachel King down her own pathway to romance in Vannetta Chapman’s A Christmas Prayer.
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? I really enjoyed listening to the audiobook of these four Christmas novellas. Each of them had a sweet romance that pulled at my heartstrings but also featured fun plotlines and interesting characters.
Christmas Grace by Mindy Steele
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.60 out of 5 stars
Grace Miller, a young woman betrayed by the man she thought loved her, finds solace and respite in Walnut Ridge when she discovers that its tight-knit community welcomes her with open arms and her future baby.
As winter nears and holiday festivities start to take shape, Grace begins to find comfort in Cullen Graber – the town’s blacksmith who is determined not let hardship consume them alone. But can they embrace God’s grace before it’s time for Grace to leave?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? I absolutely love this book because of its unique take on the pregnancy trope. The story is about forgiveness and love, and it’s written in a way that makes you root for the characters. It deals with complex themes that make it relatable to readers from all walks of life.
The Christmas Remedy by Cindy Woodsmall, Erin Woodsmall
Amish Romance, Holiday
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.10 out of 5 stars
Holly Zook is an extraordinary 24-year-old Amish woman who has been given special permission to pursue her education and work as the lead technician at Greene’s Pharmacy. With no chance of having both love and professional success, she throws herself into protecting treatable diseases from claiming more lives like that of her father.
When something unexpected puts the pharmacy in danger, Joshua Smucker–the one man whom she can’t help but be drawn to–and Holly must team up together before it gets shut down by the Board of Pharmacy. As Christmas approaches with its promise for generosity and joy will this finally bring them closer?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This book is a great read because it features a sweet romance with an interesting plotline that differs from a lot of other Amish romances. I was impressed by the author’s writing style, which is filled with vivid details and creative descriptions to bring the story to life. The characters feel very real and their journey together is truly captivating.
Amish Christmas Bride by Samantha Price
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.49 out of 5 stars
Matt Yoder was the most sought-after Amish bachelor, causing Jane to hope that he had chosen her when he asked for her return home. But instead of a proposal, she found out his plan: to be married by Christmas!
He’d narrowed down potential brides to five women but hadn’t noticed Jane’s affection for him throughout their lives together. Will it already be too late or can she find a way into his heart and become the perfect match?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This book by Samantha Price, with its intricate plotline and guaranteed happy ending, was a pleasure to read. Though the characters could be frustrating at times, I still enjoyed them and their imperfections made them all the more realistic. It wasn’t my favorite of Samantha Price’s Amish Christmas books, but it was still good in its own right.
The Story of Love by Beth Wiseman
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.48 out of 5 stars
Yvonne Wilson is looking for a change of scenery when she moves to Montgomery, Indiana and takes on the job as manager of an Amish bookstore belonging to her friends Jake and Eva Lantz. Little does she know that this move will also bring her back into contact with Abraham Byler – someone from their past who now has another relationship but still finds himself drawn to Yvonne.
Brianna, his current partner, is harboring secrets that may put them all in danger while Abraham must decide if he should pursue love or take up justice again by returning to his old Amish roots. With tensions high between everyone involved each person must make tough choices about what path they want for themselves regardless of any potential consequences it might have on their relationships
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? As someone who has read lots of romance books, I am drawn to stories that have complex characters and engaging plotlines. This is exactly what I found in this book set during the Christmas season. The second chance romance trope was particularly fun to read, as it felt like a fresh take on love in a way that resonates with anyone regardless of their life experiences.
An Amish Christmas Love: Four Novellas by Beth Wiseman, Amy Clipston, Ruth Reid, Kelly Irvin
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.25 out of 5 stars
This season, four novellas from Beth Wiseman, Amy Clipston, Kelly Irvin and Ruth Reid are set to bring joy and hope!
In ‘Winter Kisses’, readers will follow along as a young couple embarks on their first Christmas together. For Emma Bontrager in ‘The Christmas Cat’ by Amy Clipston it is her first holiday without the love of her life; but with help from unexpected visitors she learns that love still abides even after loss.
Meanwhile, David Byler has found new love Molly Shrock while struggling between his Plain faith and an old Englisch flame in Kelly Irvin’s ‘Snow Angels’. Lastly ‘Home for Christmas’ follows Ellie Whetstone who finds herself unexpectedly drawn into Amish man Ezra Mast’s home – could this be where she truly belongs?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? I loved this collection of novellas by bestselling Amish authors – it was a great way to get my fill of heartwarming romances. What I really appreciate is that the stories are quick and fun to read, but still filled with interesting characters and plot twists that keep me coming back for more.
The Christmas Singing by Cindy Woodsmall
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.20 out of 5 stars
Mattie Eash and Gideon Beiler have known each other since childhood, but when faced with unexpected obstacles he breaks off their engagement on Christmas Eve. Three years later, returning to Apple Ridge for the holidays may bring her restoration or deeper heartache – as she must confront his dishonesty head-on and face what still binds them together. Join Mattie in a story of love, romance, pain, and redemption this holiday season!
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This book is a great read because it features interesting, complex characters. I especially enjoyed the second chance romance aspect of this story. This theme brings out the best in human emotions, providing an interesting yet realistic view of how relationships can be rekindled even after mistakes have been made.
First Christmas on Huckleberry Hill by Jennifer Beckstrand
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.53 out of 5 stars
Anna and Felty Helmuth, two eighty-somethings from Huckleberry Hill, Wisconsin have become beloved matchmakers. In their youth, however, the couple were mismatched lovers with seemingly insurmountable obstacles standing in their way.
Despite her lack of domestic skills and preference for helping those in need over being a perfect Amish maiden. Anna reached out to her old schoolmate Felty who had been ostracized by his community for serving during the Korean War. With faith at its core, this holiday season will be one that proves they are indeed meant to be together forevermore!
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This is a full-length prequel of grandparents, Anna and Felty, telling their love story. It’s an adorable, heartwarming romance that brings out all the feels. The unique writing style makes the characters come to life in such vivid detail.
An Amish Christmas at the Apple Blossom Inn by Tracy Fredrychowski, Debra Torres
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4.83 out of 5 stars
Orphaned just weeks before Christmas, sisters Sadie and Katie Beiler are struggling to keep their home from being lost. Forced into working at Willow Spring’s Apple Blossom Inn for survival, they must fight against adversity while trying to bring joy back to both their family and all of Willow Springs.
With pride clouding her judgment, can Sadie make amends with Jubal King in order to save not only herself but also the inn? Meanwhile, Katie is urged by faith alone on a quest of discovery when Jeremiah Hershberger comes seeking answers about his past – will these two intrepid young women find hope amidst despair this holiday season?
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? This was a quick and fun read that had me laughing out loud at some of the funny moments.
What I especially enjoyed was the heartwarming family dynamics and dialogue that really brought the characters to life. There were also some really sweet moments of romance throughout the book. It was great to see characters finding love and happiness.
Christmas at the Amish Market by Shelley Shepard Gray
Amish Romance
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.19 out of 5 stars
This holiday season, Wesley has too much to manage at his family’s Amish market and finds an unexpected helper in Jenny – the charming young aunt of Liesl whom he had been courting for years.
Despite their initial hesitation about getting romantically involved due to a possible clash between what Liesl expects from him and her own feelings, both Jenny & Wesley discover that they share a special connection which leads them on an unlikely journey of love with some help from their community friends.
🎄 Why you should read this Amish Christmas novel? I love this Amish Christmas book because it offers a unique combination of holiday fun, sweet romance, and realistic characters. The holiday-themed story is full of festive cheer, and the HEA (happily ever after) ending is sure to put a smile on your face.
Did you discover the best Amish Christmas books?
We hope you’ve enjoyed this list of some of the best Amish Christmas books for women. Whether you’re looking for a heartwarming family story, a sweet romance, or an unexpected journey into love and faith – these books have something special to offer. The Christian Book Store has some other great Amish holiday books to read as well.
So make sure to add them to your TBR list – and don’t forget to get our free printable book journal so that you can keep track of all your holiday reading!
