12 Best Christian Fiction Books Set in the 1920s

Have you been wondering about Christian fiction books set in the 1920s? I’ve got you covered!

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from purchases made through the affiliate links included in this post. This means if you click on the link and make a purchase, I will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. See the Privacy Policy for more information.

Ah, the roaring ’20s! Flapper dresses, jazz music, bootleggers, and a sense of unbridled optimism that had everyone kicking up their heels! 🎉 It’s a decade that saw an explosion of creativity and defiance of the status quo.

And who can resist the allure of time-traveling through literature to this glitzy era of American history? I’ve waved my bookworm magic wand (yes, I have one of those) and conjured up a list that will transport you straight into the heart of the 1920s—with a Christian fiction twist, no less.

You can trust me on this one; I’ve rummaged through dusty bookstore shelves, connected with fellow literature aficionados, and done my literary homework to bring you the creme de la creme of this historic decade’s reads.

So, grab your cloche hat, my fellow bibliophiles, because we’re about to embark on a journey that’s both enlightening and downright entertaining.

Ready to be romanced by rich historical details and inspired by timeless spiritual lessons? Thought so! Let’s dive in!

1. The Metropolitan Affair by Jocelyn Green

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 3.85 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

Assistant curator and Egyptology aficionado, Dr. Lauren Westlake, juggles a renewed offer from her estranged dad for an Egyptian adventure with an unexpected plea from the law to solve an art fraud rocking New York’s elite.

Thrust into a scandal interwoven with Egypt’s ancient allure, she partners with dogged Detective Joe Caravello to catch a cunning forger amidst the city’s frenzy for all things Tutankhamun.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

The characters in the story were absolutely captivating! They had such depth and underwent significant growth as the plot unfolded.

And the 1920s New York vibe mixed with Egyptian art? Spot-on. You’re practically time-traveling to that era. Plus, the mystery? It keeps you guessing until the last page.

2. The Shepherd’s Voice by Robin Lee Hatcher

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.50 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

Gabe Talmadge, who got wrongly convicted and spent a decade in prison, comes back to his hometown during the Great Depression. Struggling to survive and rejected by his father, he finds a glimmer of hope when Akira Macauley offers him a place to stay and work on a sheep ranch.

But as tragedy strikes and Gabe’s life falls apart, he’s faced with a choice: succumb to despair or hold on to faith, hope, and a love that surpasses anything he’s ever known.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

This book dives into deep themes of faith, forgiveness, and listening to God’s voice in our lives. It really makes you think about your own choices and your own walk with God. It’s perfect for a book club, trust me!

Plus, the romance is more of a subplot making it perfect for readers who prefer less romance.

🤩 Check Prices Here!

3. Wonderland Creek by Lynn Austin

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.29 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance, Mystery | ✅ Read it!

Alice Grace Ripley’s life takes an unexpected turn when her boyfriend ends their relationship, accusing her of living in a realm of fiction. She escapes to the mountains of eastern Kentucky in the town of Acorn to deliver donated books to a coal-mining community.

As she becomes entangled in Acorn’s embrace, Alice discovers real-life adventures, mysteries, and romance that surpass her humble dreams.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

I’m a huge fan of Lynn Austin, and let me tell you, this book is an absolute gem! The storyline had me hooked from start to finish, and I couldn’t get enough of the amazing characters.

Oh, and there’s a bit of a love triangle, but don’t worry, the romance is so sweet and heartwarming. Trust me, this book is an absolute delight to read!

“That’s absurd,” I said with a little laugh. “Nobody can read too much. That’s like saying someone breathes too much.”

― Lynn Austin, Wonderland Creek

🤩 Check Prices Here!

4. The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus by Jaime Jo Wright

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.07 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Mystery Thriller | ✅ Read it!

In 1928, Pippa Ripley, an outcast from the Bonaventure Circus, embarks on a quest to uncover her origins. As she delves into her search, she crosses paths with a man seeking justice for his sister’s murder and discovers evidence of a serial killer haunting the circus train.

In the present day, Chandler Faulk, a real estate project manager, faces the decision of demolishing or preserving the old circus train depot. As she navigates her recent autoimmune disease diagnosis and the pressures of single motherhood, tantalizing clues to unresolved past murders draw Chandler into a chilling and foreboding narrative surrounding the abandoned train depot.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

This book is just so captivating, with its dual timeline that keeps you hooked. And the spooky, gothic circus setting? It adds a whole new level of allure! Jamie Jo Wright, the author, is a master at weaving together the past and present, keeping readers engrossed until the wee hours.

The characters are so vividly portrayed, and I absolutely loved how disabilities were represented.

🤩 Check Prices Here!

5. Great Waters by Jennifer Q. Hunt

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.74 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

Haunted by his past, Russell Carver leads a pretty solitary life in Boston until he crosses paths with Katie Sweet. Their encounter sparks something in him, reigniting forgotten aspirations and igniting a deep devotion.

As their relationship grows, they face a whole bunch of challenges that put their love to the ultimate test. Can they handle family conflicts, heart-wrenching losses, and a whole bunch of dark secrets?

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

I really enjoyed the characters in this book! It’s amazing to see how they grow and redeem themselves throughout the story. And the faith themes that focus on God’s forgiveness add so much depth.

Just a heads up, though, there’s quite a bit of content warnings at the beginning, so it’s not recommended for young adult readers. Make sure to check it out beforehand!

🤩 Check Prices Here!

6. The Mobster’s Daughter by Rachel Scott McDaniel

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.53 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance, Mystery | ✅ Read it!

Kate Chamberlin, a talented musician working for KDKA radio, leads a double life as the daughter of a notorious crime boss.

When she starts receiving anonymous threats, she hesitates to accept Detective Jennings’ help, even though he’s determined to protect her. With danger looming, the revelation of Kate’s past could be the key to their survival.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

I was totally hooked by the incredible amount of historical detail in this story, spanning from the prohibition era to the world of gangsters and beyond. The mystery had me captivated right from the start and held my interest throughout.

And let me tell you, the romance? It was just so beautifully gradual and tender. The characters? Oh boy, they were so well-developed, I felt like I knew them personally.

“I had a heart that’d been built to outlast earthquakes, withstand stormy seas, but to stare into the eyes of a man I could never have? That was pain beyond recovery.”

― Rachel Scott McDaniel, The Mobster’s Daughter

🤩 Check Prices Here!

7. Shadowed Loyalty by Roseanna M. White

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.23 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

Sabina Mancari, daughter of a prominent Chicago mob boss, has her world shattered when she learns her love interest is an undercover Prohibition agent. As she uncovers family secrets, she faces a dilemma: escape with her fiancé or remain loyal.

Meanwhile, Lorenzo struggles between his dreams and family expectations, unintentionally pushing Sabina towards the agent determined to dismantle her family. In the midst of the Mafia’s dark empire, they must navigate their complex relationship and rebuild what has been neglected.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

This book is just so beautifully crafted, you won’t be able to put it down! The characters are so intricate and the plot will seriously keep you on the edge of your seat. And let me tell you, the author fearlessly tackles some real-life stuff with such grace and courage.

The themes explored are so relevant and relatable that anyone can enjoy this read.

🤩 Check Prices Here!

8. In High Cotton by Ane Mulligan

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.57 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Fiction | ✅ Read it!

In rural South Georgia during the prosperous 1920s, widow Maggie Parker faces the challenges of raising her son alone amidst life’s hardships.

With collapsing banks and her father-in-law threatening to take her son and sell her late husband’s grocery store, Maggie relies on the wisdom and cunning of five extraordinary Southern women to outsmart him and navigate the treacherous waters of the Great Depression.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

This book is absolutely amazing! It’s packed with lots of action that will keep you hooked until the late hours of the night. And let me tell you, the attention to historical details is spot on!

It really immerses you in the story and makes it so fun to dive into. But what truly captivated me are the deep and meaningful friendships between the women and the inspiring faith themes that run through every aspect of their lives.

🤩 Check Prices Here!

9. Above the Fold by Rachel Scott McDaniel

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.40 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

Elissa Tillman, a secretary with a passion for journalism, yearns to secure a headline that will save her father’s struggling newspaper. When she gets the chance to compete against her former flame, renowned journalist Cole Parker, to cover a murder story, Elissa must decide between her dreams and her heart.

Meanwhile, Cole is determined to redeem himself and win back Elissa’s love. Will they be able to overcome their past and find a future together?

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

The plot captivated me with its engaging and expertly crafted narrative, bringing the vibrant streets of Pittsburgh during the Roaring Twenties to life.

Every little detail, from the gritty atmosphere to the allure of speakeasies and the world of journalism, was vividly captured. The characters were strong and their second chance romance enchanting, leaving me swooning with delight.

🤩 Check Prices Here!

10. The Illusionist’s Apprentice by Kristy Cambron

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 3.81 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance, Mystery | ✅ Read it!

Jenny “Wren” Lockhart, a former apprentice of Harry Houdini, has some fascinating secrets about the famous illusionist. As she navigates the unconventional world of vaudeville in 1926 Boston, Wren finds herself caught up in a web of mystery surrounding a spiritualist named Horace Stapleton.

With the FBI on her side, Wren races against the clock to prove the innocence of a despised man while her carefully constructed world threatens to crumble.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

This book is an amazing combination of historical fiction and a thrilling mystery set in the 1920s. The well-developed characters and the author’s exploration of illusion and magic make it a mind-blowing read. The book also touches on faith themes in a light and relatable way.

With plot twists that will leave you shocked, this is a captivating story that you won’t be able to put down.

“If there was no darkness, there would be no opportunity for light to overcome it.”

― Kristy Cambron, The Illusionist’s Apprentice

🤩 Check Prices Here!

11. Where the Fire Falls by Karen Barnett

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.09 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

Set in Yosemite National Park in the late 1920s, this enchanting love story follows Olivia Rutherford, a talented watercolorist on a daring journey to escape poverty and reinvent herself as an avant-garde artist. With a dream to illustrate the park, she hopes it will be her big breakthrough.

Clark Johnson, a former minister turned backcountry guide, introduces her to the wonders of Yosemite, making him question his true calling. As Olivia unravels the park’s captivating tales and meets fascinating individuals, her carefully crafted façade may crumble.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

I absolutely adored the historical setting of the Yosemite park! The author truly brought it to life, making me feel like I was right there. And let me tell you, the characters were fantastic!

They went through so much growth by the end of the book, it was incredible. Oh, and the romance? It was seriously the sweetest thing ever!

🤩 Check Prices Here!

12. The Lost Girl of Astor Street by Stephanie Morrill

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.05 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Mystery, Romance | ✅ Read it!

Lydia’s sudden disappearance hits Piper hard, leaving her devastated and determined to take matters into her own hands. With unwavering resolve, Piper joins forces with a charming detective and plunges into the gritty underbelly of 1924 Chicago.

As she unravels the enigma, she comes to a startling realization that corruption may lurk closer to home than she ever imagined. Piper faces tough choices and puts everything on the line, including her own life, in her relentless pursuit to find Lydia and uncover the truth.

Why should you dive into this book set in the roaring 20s?

The 1920s setting completely sucked me in, and I seriously loved every single minute of it! The writing style was so immersive, and the dialogue? I mean, it was just awesome.

And let’s not forget the characters – they were seriously amazing! I couldn’t get enough of reading about them, they were all so complex. Oh, and can we talk about the romance? It was swoon-worthy to the max!

🤩 Check Prices Here!

• Get a free trial of Audible: Enjoy 30 days of free access to thousands of audiobooks, and pick one premium title for free. Perfect for listening on the go!
• Try Kindle Unlimited for free: Dive into 30 days of unlimited ebook reading on any device. You’ll get instant access to over two million titles!
• Experience Amazon Prime for free: Enjoy a 30-day trial offering free two-day shipping on all purchases, plus access to hundreds of new ebooks every month.
• Discover Libro.fm: Support your local bookstore and receive 2 audiobook credits as a new member!