Closed Door vs Open Door Books: Plus 5 Clean Romance Reads

So, what is a closed door romance book? I’ve got you covered!

Hey my bookish best friend!

You’re probably wondering what the buzz about closed door romances also known as a fade to black scene is all about, right? Well, think of it like this: you know that moment when things start heating up between the characters and you’re getting all the swoons, but then – poof! – the door closes, and the rest is left to your imagination. 

That’s a closed door romance for you. It’s all the feels, the connection, the butterflies, without the sex scenes. As someone who’s spent more hours with her nose in a book than I care to admit (but, hey, who’s counting?), I’ve accidentally seen my fair share of blush-worthy scenes that I had to skip over. 

And I get it – you want the romance without the explicit nitty-gritty. Whether it’s for personal preference or comfort, clean reads are a gem, and I’m here as your bookish guide to navigate through them. 

Trust me, this is my favorite genre, and I know you romance readers are on the lookout for these kinds of books.

So, let’s dive into the world of closed door romances together. You ready?

What is closed-door romance novel?

Alright, let’s break it down – a closed door romance book is basically the G-rated, sweet neighbor of the romance genre. Imagine all the buildup, the chemistry that practically crackles off the page, but when things start heading toward the bedroom, the story suddenly cuts to the morning after – with a pair of wrinkled shirts, a knowing smirk, and a happy ending. 

It’s romance that focuses on the emotional depth and the journey of the relationship rather than the physical aspect. 

• All About the Anticipation: Just like waiting for a pot of water to boil – it’s all about that slow build, that anticipation of delicious pasta, I promise you.
• Character Chemistry Off the Charts: We’re talking characters with sparks so real you’ll be wearing safety goggles.
• Flirty Banter for Days: Who needs explicit content when you’ve got wit and wordplay sharper than a brand-new box of crayons, right?
• Sweet, Sweet Romance: Like your fave snuggly blanket, it’s all about the warm fuzzies and the tender moments that have you grinning like you just found chocolate in your pocket.
• Safe for Public Consumption: Read it anywhere – on the bus, at the in-laws’, you name it, without blushing like a tomato or hiding the cover.

As you can see, it’s perfect for readers who love to root for the lovebirds but prefer to keep things on the PG side of the party. 

So, if you’re into heartfelt confessions, stolen kisses under the stars, and hands brushing against hands that send your heart racing, then close the door romances are gonna be your jam!

Why do people read closed-door romances?

So, why do people opt for closed-door romances over open-door ones? Well, for me, I tend to skip books with spicy scenes due to my religious beliefs. But for others, it could simply be that they’re not fans of reading intimate moments.

Here are some popular reasons why people may prefer closed-door romances:

• Personal preference: Some folks simply prefer skipping intimate scenes to focus on the emotional connection between characters.
• Comfort level: Explicit content might not sit well with certain readers, causing discomfort or triggering feelings. Closed-door romances offer a safe, cozy reading experience for such individuals.
• Moral/religious beliefs: As mentioned earlier, some readers hold personal or religious beliefs that clash with explicit content. Closed-door romances provide a way for them to enjoy romantic tales while staying true to their values.
• Portrayal of healthy relationships: Open-door romances often emphasize physical intimacy, potentially overshadowing emotional relationship aspects. Closed-door romances tend to highlight emotional connections and the growth of character development. 
• Versatility: Closed-door romances can attract a broader audience beyond those who seek explicit content, making them more inclusive and adaptable in appealing to different groups.

Open door romance novels vs closed door

In the world of romance novels, there are two main categories when it comes to intimate scenes: open-door and closed-door romances. Open-door romances include explicit content and detailed descriptions of sexual encounters, while closed-door romances tend to fade to black or skip over those scenes entirely.

Here is a breakdown of the main difference between the two and why closed-door romances have their own unique appeal.

• Heat Levels: Closed-door romances are all about the slow burn, longing glances, swoony kisses, and a possible fade to black scene. On the flip side, open-door romances don’t shy away from the steam; they crank it up and bring out all the feels, and yes, that might have you blushing!
• Focus Points: With closed-door romances, it’s all about those cozy moments, right? We’re talking deep conversations at 2 AM, shared laughs, and those adorable, quirky gestures that make you go, ‘Aw, they’re perfect!’ Open-door romances? They’re not just about the chit-chat – they dive deep into the passion, laying it all out on the table.
• Audience: Closed-door romances are your go-to when you’re chilling with Grandma, and you don’t want an awkward moment when she asks what ‘that’ word means. Anyone can pick them up for a feel-good read. Meanwhile in an open-door romance novel – well, you might not want to leave those lying around just anywhere, unless you want to give someone a surprise!
• Settings and Scenarios: Picture this: Closed-door romances are like that glowing, cozy coffee shop date in a Hallmark movie. They’re all about the atmosphere and leaving some things to your imagination. But open-door romances, they’re like that Vegas trip in a rom-com – they promise you a wild ride and deliver all of the exciting details, leaving nothing to the imagination.
• Impact on Relationship Development: Ever think about how the characters actually get from flirty banter to ‘I’d marry you in a heartbeat’? Closed-door romances focus on the journey there, highlighting emotional bonding, shared dreams, and all the foundations. Open-door romances, though, they’re more upfront, showing you every step – and I mean every step – of the way, including how their physical relationships.
• Variety of Themes: Whether it’s about that surprising office romance or bumping into Mr. Right at the dog park, closed-door romances cover a wide range of themes that could happen to anyone, anytime. Now, open-door romances have this too, but with the added addition of explicit scenes.

Remember, whether you’re in the mood for something sweet or looking to spice things up, it’s all about your OWN personal preference.

2. Magic Forged by K.M. Shea

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.31 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Urban Fantasy Romance | ✅ Read it!

Hazel, a resourceful wizard with a sprinkle of magic, finds herself in a tough spot when she steps up as the leader of her wizard clan following a tragic event. 

Turning to the notorious vampire, Killian Drake, she aims to protect her family from a deceitful cousin. 

In their journey through magic, Hazel uncovers her hidden strengths and sets off on a path of resilience and survival.

Why you might want to read this closed-door romance?

If you’re all about awesome conversations and characters that feel totally real and relatable, this series is a must-read.

The character interactions and dialogues are so lively and heartwarming that you can’t help but get emotionally invested. Plus, with the immersive world-building and fantasy romance, it’s a captivating blend that’ll keep you totally hooked.

Buy on Amazon

3. A Loyal Heart by Jody Hedlund

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.34 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Christian Historical Romance | ✅ Read it!

When Lady Olivia’s castle faces a siege, she and her sister become captives of Lord Pitt, and face uncertain futures. Driven by loyalty, Olivia is determined to rescue her sister at any cost, even if it means daring to steal a sacred relic. 

Amidst peril and betrayal, can Olivia defy her arranged match to wed the gallant knight, Aldric, who schemes to save her? Loyalties are put to the test as they confront dangers that could endanger their love and lives.

Why you might want to read this closed-door romance?

Jody Hedlund is a master at crafting vibrant historical novels. This story dives into a medieval world of knights, packed with action, Christian values, and a captivating romance. 

Definitely a gem for your collection of wholesome historical romance reads!

Buy on Amazon

4. Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.09 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: YA Fantasy Romance | ✅ Read it!

Evangeline Fox was a firm believer in true love until the moment she discovered her beloved was about to marry another. 

Desperate to halt the wedding, she strikes a deal with the wicked Prince of Hearts for three kisses. Little did she know the peril of bargaining with an immortal, as his intentions exceeded their initial agreement. Will this tale culminate in a fairy-tale conclusion or a tragic twist?

Why you might want to read this closed-door romance?

This book is like a treasured gem in the fantasy romance world!

The romance is so captivating that you might just stay up all night to see how it unfolds. The characters are lovable, and the dialogues are simply delightful.

And let’s not forget the fairy tale vibes that will transport you back to your childhood with an enchanting twist.

“I don’t know if I can fix your broken heart, but you can take mine because it’s already yours.”

― Stephanie Garber, Once Upon a Broken Heart

Buy on Amazon

5. How to Kiss Your Grumpy Boss by Jenny Proctor

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 4.08 out of 5 Stars | 📚 Genre: Contemporary Romantic Comedy | ✅ Read it!

Perry Hawthorne, Lila’s boss, brings her on as a virtual assistant, keeping things strictly professional despite underlying emotions. 

When their interaction moves to face-to-face encounters, Lila uncovers a new side of Perry. With their chemistry growing, Lila grapples with the idea of risking a budding relationship due to past experiences and her son’s well-being.

Why you might want to read this closed-door romance?

The book’s charm gets a boost from its fall setting, the single mom trope, and the one-bed situation. Lila, the main character, skillfully dives into life’s complexities, highlighting body positivity, a refreshing theme in romance lit that promotes inclusivity. 

The witty banter, filled with playful exchanges, brings a light-hearted vibe that complements the book’s deeper messages.

Buy on Amazon

FAQs about Closed Door Romance Novel’s